Things Found While Job Hunting: My Encounter With a Craigslist Fetishist

A few months ago, I applied to a job on Craigslist. This isn’t out of the ordinary. I run a writing business and browse the writing ads on Craigslist with regularity. My interest is piqued when I come across ads looking for fiction writers. “You mean you want to pay me to write fiction?” my eager brain asks. “Yes, please!”

In this case, the ad I found was a bit…interesting. It went like this:

I am interested in having a short story written, about 3 to 5 pages in length, the concept being a twenty- or thirty-something professional woman who wears high heels regularly despite suffering foot problems. The style could be 3rd person, in the manner of “chick lit.” It could also be first person, in the style of a blog entry. What is a “day in the life” like of a woman who willingly sacrifices comfort and the health of her feet for excruciatingly beautiful shoes?

To say an alarm didn’t go off in my head screaming “Weird” at the top of its warbley lungs would be, of course, a lie. But being the desperate writer that I am, I applied anyway. I thought hey, maybe this person is trying to use a social media slant for selling shoes. Or maybe it’s supposed to be for a women’s site or publication with a funny take on “the things we do for beauty.” Turns out, I should have trusted my instincts.

My application apparently impressed. A man responded saying I seemed perfect for the task. He wanted to know what approach I would take to this story. I shot back a quick response saying I could write about a retail worker who wears extremely fashionable shoes to bring a bit of glamour to her day. Apparently, he loved this idea and wanted to chat via IM.

Luckily, I had already Googled this individual by then. Needless to say, I didn’t respond to his last e-mail or agree to a chat. I did the closest thing to running away from a person online possible: ignore, ignore, ignore.

So, what did my crafty* Googling turn up?

First of all, a Twitter account devoted to shoes. Specifically, “sexy” shoes. He made numerous @ replies to women asking what shoes they were wearing and if they’d spent tons of money of shoes.

I’m talking shoe fetish, here. And not that cutesy, “oh I love to buy shoes so I have a shoe fetish” thing so many people like to dish out. I mean a real deal, legitimate shoe fetish. Unfortunately, that’s not where this story ends.

Apparently, this guy doesn’t just love super high heeled shoes. He loves shoes that make women’s feet hurt. I’m sure the shoes themselves are mighty interesting, but the fact that they cause a woman pain give him undeniable pleasure.


High heels aren't enough. They have to hurt, too.

*Okay, so it wasn’t crafty. Just typing in a name, really. At least he wasn’t hiding his kinks.

Even worse, he loves it when women have bunions. He even asked women on Twitter when/if they were having painful surgery on their painful bunions. This led me to discover the account of another writer who came across a similar ad he’d posted months earlier and who had taken this thing a step further: she actually wrote him a story. From her account, it wasn’t a bad experience, and who am I to judge? I just got weirded out with the prospect of having to converse with this guy.

Because it seemed very much to me that he didn’t just want a story written (that it seems he would’ve actually paid for) but he wanted that conversation. The lead up to the end result was very much a part of the experience. I would have been asked questions about my shoes, then my feet, then any defects my feet had. I would have been asked for pictures. And I just couldn’t deal with that.

Don’t get me wrong. I’m no prude. I’ve taken a stab at erotica and would write it again. But this just wasn’t my thing.

At the end of the day, this guy wanted a relationship with whomever was writing his stories, even in just an imaginary way. And while you can’t control what people think of you, it is possible to avoid making yourself (or your feet) a person’s fetishistic target to some extent. It sort of makes you want to cover your body in a wool scarf, doesn’t it? Damn, someone out there’s probably into that, too.

Thank god I didn’t mention I used to dance and have real life, non-imaginary (albeit, tiny) bunions.

Have you encountered oddness while searching for work? Share your stories below!

9 thoughts on “Things Found While Job Hunting: My Encounter With a Craigslist Fetishist

  1. TY: Ha! A guy asked you to step on him? That is definitely interesting. Fetishes intrigue and confuse me.

    Sarah: I don’t even know what it could be categorized as. Combination shoe and foot fetish with a dash of sadism? Yikes, is all I can say.

  2. This guy himself could make an interesting character for a story… Probably not a protagonist, mind you!
    Craigslist turns up some interesting things. I recall seeing a preschool teacher wanting to hire someone to dress up as Hitler returned from the dead, and come to the preschool to help with a lesson on tolerance (Hitler being the bad example of this). Pretty amusing…

  3. Hi Brenda,

    I stumbled upon your June 30th post today. (Yes, I search blog posts as well as Tweets for bunion content.) As in the case of the other author, who wrote an article about her experience working with me, hearing the other person’s perspective gives me new insights into myself.

    As opposed to liking long hair, or blue eyes, or big boobs or butts, being attracted to feet is something that’s often stigmatized, and women with bunions are usually very self-conscious about them. The role which pain plays in all of this is something I still haven’t figured out completely… I love it without knowing exactly why I do. In any event, rather than pursue these desires in real life (should anyone pick a partner on the basis of her feet?), I explore my attraction through fantasy, and the stories I purchase have been an effective outlet for that. I was amused to learn that you have bunions yourself, but I don’t always ask for pictures to accompany the stories. The desire to chat was twofold… one, in the past I’ve paid money to people who were way off the mark in what they produced for me. And secondly, you’re right, I do prefer a connection with the story writers, because it’s such a relief to be able to openly express this desire and experience a degree acceptance (even if it’s just because there’s money involved).

    Thanks again for posting about your experience!

  4. Nicholas: Hitler for preschool? I mean, first of all, wouldn’t a picture of Hitler sufficed? And do kids that little even understand that subject matter? lol Craigslist is an interesting place.

    D.S.: Wow, I never thought about you actually finding this post, which makes me naive, I suppose. Glad to hear your side of the situation, though. Everyone has things that they’re into and I appreciate that you’re taking the fantasy route. The Internet is an interesting and sometimes unsettling place in that you never know who’s on the other side of the screen. I hope you didn’t take offense. One just has to be careful, you know.

    • Brenda, as I said in e-mail, no offense. 🙂

      But it seems you’re back in “ignore” mode. I was hoping you’d be interested in the story project, particularly with the horror tie-in. If so, please write me. Otherwise best wishes for future success, and I’ll leave you alone.

  5. All that research on the guy, even finding someone who did write him a story, and we still don’t know how much he was paying??

    I also wonder if he cares if the writer is a man?? A man who wears painful high heels and has painful bunions??

    Oooooo, this is getting thrilling!!!

    (at the top of my weird stack is Dan Savage licking doorknobs at Republican campaign offices – google it)

    • I’m not really sure how much he was going to pay. I think from the other writer who did actually write for him, the rate was decent. Well, decent for Craigslist. It’s just interesting to me. He seems to be a complex stew of fetish.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s